Latest News Posts

Social
Latest Forum Posts

…And the Winner of Next-Gen is: PlayStation 4 (Unless Microsoft Fixes Things)
Bookmark and Share

PS4 versus Xbox One
Print
by Rob Williams on June 12, 2013 in Gaming, Staff Editorials

With both Microsoft and Sony having laid everything out on the table at E3, there’s no better time than the present to peruse it all and see which one comes out ahead. Well – as the title of this article suggests, one of these companies has some work to do if it wants to win the next round of the console war.

Prior to the announcements for Sony’s PlayStation 4 or Microsoft’s Xbox One, I couldn’t have ever guessed that things were going to be so interesting. Unfortunately, some of the biggest reasons things are so interesting is because of how negatively certain decisions impact consumers. With E3, many of our long-awaited questions were finally answered, and now, we’re finally able to take a hard look at both offerings and see which one comes out ahead.

I could just wrap things up here and say “PlayStation 4″, but that’d make for a poor article.

I’m a regular Reddit user, and frequent some of the most popular gaming sub-Reddits every day, including /r/games. While I don’t talk too much there, I do pay attention to some trends, and over the past couple of months, the tides have certainly changed. Heck – just look at how things have changed since the PlayStation 3’s launch.

At the Xbox 360’s launch, I had no doubts about it being a fantastic console. I was a day-one purchaser and never had any regrets. I was a bit tardy on the PlayStation 3 side, buying one about six months after launch, and I can honestly say that I did regret that one. It wasn’t because of a lack of games or other media capabilities – far from it. Instead, it was because of how Sony began to treat its customers, not to mention how it managed to eff-up time and time again.

Microsoft Xbox One
Microsoft’s $499 Xbox One

No one liked the Red Ring of Death problem on the Microsoft side (I’ve suffered it twice over), but over time, it became more of a joke than anything. Still, that incident made Sony look oh-so-good… but not for long. Sony’s decision to re-release the PS3 sans PS2 emulation came forth, and rubbed many the wrong way (including me). Then it decided to purge the ability to run Linux simply because of some security issues (which were very quickly worked over even after Linux was gone). Folding@home? Also gone.

And of course, no one will forget the Great PSN Compromise of 2011.

Sony PlayStation 4
Sony’s $399 PlayStation 4

If there’s one thing I’ve discovered since then, it’s that brand loyalty only goes so far. When you begin working against your fans, effectively ruining the experiences you’ve sold them, they’re likely to turn on you. While Microsoft’s RRoD issue was undoubtedly severe, the customer impact towards Sony seemed to be even worse, with its mounting problems.

After the PlayStation Network breach occurred, many claimed they’d never support Sony again… ever. I have a couple of friends who vehemently believe that. Opinions like that around the Web seemed common as well. So it’s fun, then, to fast-forward to today. As mentioned above, the tides have changed.

Few would argue that Sony’s PS4 unveiling this past February was poor, what with a total lack of a glimpse at the console itself. Then again, at that time, Microsoft hadn’t officially announced anything either. None of us knew how things were going to play out, what Microsoft had up its sleeve. That was until May 21st, that is, when Microsoft finally showed off its Xbox One for the world to see.

Leading up to that launch, the Xbox One had faced a great number of rumors; not all of them great. Just prior to E3, most of those were verified by Microsoft itself. At E3, the issues only became even more glaring.

With all that Microsoft and Sony have revealed so far, it seems clear to me that the next-generation champion is the PlayStation 4. Before we get into the reasons (some of them already obvious), let’s break down the consoles themselves:

 
Hardware CPU: AMD Jaguar 8-core
GPU: 1152 Radeon Cores
Memory: 8GB GDDR51
HDD: 500GB
ODD: Blu-ray, DVD
CPU: AMD Jaguar 8-core
GPU: 768 Radeon Cores
Memory: 8GB DDR32
HDD: 500GB
ODD: Blu-ray, DVD
Display 1080p & 4K3
HDMI
1080p & 4K3
HDMI
Audio HDMI
Optical (S/PDIF)
HDMI
Optical (S/PDIF)
Online Capabilities PlayStation Plus required for MP
Doesn’t require Internet access for gaming
Xbox Live Gold required for MP
Requires daily Internet access for gaming
Backwards Compatibility Yes, via Gaikai 4 None
Game Inputs DualShock 4 controller (Enhancements include touchpad, built-in speaker and “Share” button)
Games can be streamed to the PSP Vita
Xbox One controller (Enhancement includes trigger vibration)
Xbox SmartGlass capabilities
Used Games No restrictions for physical copy
Requires etailer proxy for sales
Cannot trade digital copies
Limit of 1 sale per physical copy
Cannot trade digital copies
Multimedia Capabilities Music, Movies, Photos, TV
Streaming Content5
Music, Movies, Photos, TV
Streaming Content5
Other Capabilities Game Recording
Cloud Profiles
Cross Game Chat
Free Games w/ Plus Sub6
No region locking
Game Recording
Cloud Profiles
Cross Game Chat
Voice activation w/ Kinect
Pricing $399.99 (USD)
£349.99 (~$550 USD)
€399.99 (~$535 USD)
$499.99 (USD)
£429.99 (~$675 USD)
€499.99 (~$665 USD)
UK and Euro price conversions as of June 11, 2013
1 7GB available to games.
2 5GB available to games.
3 The vast majority of games are expected to render at 1080p on both consoles, although 4K is technically possible for lesser-demanding titles.
4 Specifics are still scarce.
5 Specific service support expected to be revealed near launch.
6 Free games indefinitively require a Plus subscription to be accessed.

On paper, the PS4 looks to be more powerful than the Xbox One, boasting 50% more Radeon cores, but that to me doesn’t matter at this point. We’ll have to see how either company optimizes AMD’s hardware, and how the PS4’s reliance on GDDR5 over standard desktop DDR3 will pan out. It appears Sony’s console is the clear-cut champ, but there’s too little information to warrant speculation (at least on my part).

Both consoles support 1080p, and while Microsoft has alluded to the fact that 4K gaming is also possible, it’s undoubtedly going to be limited to modest titles. Even a $500 desktop GPU would be iffy with most current games at that resolution (effectively 1080p x 4), so it’s not realistic to expect that AMD’s desktop-derived APU is going deliver some sort of miracle.

As of this next generation, both the Xbox and PlayStation will require subscriptions to their respective premium services for multiplayer access. Currently, PlayStation Plus can be had for $50 per year, while Xbox Live Gold is $60 per year. At the current time, Microsoft hasn’t announced plans to give its subscribers free game titles on occasion, while that’s already become a popular perk for PlayStation gamers (and one that many I’ve talked to tell me keeps them subscribed).

This though, along with everything else, is mostly fluff. Both consoles are going to offer perks that the other doesn’t have. Some might love the free game aspect of Plus, while others could prefer Microsoft’s SmartGlass functionality or built-in Kinect. Both consoles can record games, store saves and other things in the cloud, and will offer a wide-range of multimedia services for your perusal, such as TV, movies, music and so forth.

If I stopped writing here, both consoles would appear to be on a fairly level playing field. But obviously, that’s not the case. While not everything on Sony’s side is perfect, it’s Microsoft that’s been suffering an enormous amount of flak from its fans and non-fans alike in recent weeks. The sickening thing? It’s all for things that could be changed at the drop of a hat.

Why PlayStation 4 Has Won This Round (If Microsoft Changes Nothing)

Required Per-24 Hours Internet Check-in – Up until the recent used games debacle, this was without question the biggest issue that people had against the Xbox One. No one likes needless requirements, and this is about as needless as it gets. It’s the type of issue that not everyone may understand at first, but everyone has the potential to face head-on at some point.

Xbox One - VCR Offline
Credit: Random_Bee

I moved at the start of May, and due to a major ISP screw-up, I went three straight weeks without reliable Internet. The only reason I had any at all outside of my phone was because I have a sister that lives nearby that I was able to borrow a signal from. Had I owned an Xbox One and not had that borrowed Internet privilege, I would have been shit out of luck – completely unable to play the games I purchased. But this is the kind of situation that’s rare, I admit. What’s less-than-rare are our troops overseas who are lucky to get access to the Internet at all, much less make sure their game console that helps them retain some sanity can get online as well.

What about if you’re going camping, or if you want to rent a cabin in the middle of the woods? When in the great outdoors, Internet access just isn’t expected, and after all that smores-making, it’s fun to be able to game it up before hitting the hay. But it’s not going to happen for a lot of people. Maybe Microsoft has secret dealings with Hasbro and Parker Brothers to sell more board games?

One-time Used Game Sale – On both the Xbox and PS4 side, used game policies haven’t been clear until just recently, and until yesterday, even Sony’s interaction with used games was questionable. Well, we now have our answer from Sony, but what about Microsoft? Those were discovered last week, and as expected, the answers are hardly what gamers wanted to hear.

PlayStation 4 No Used Games Restrictions
Sony milking this for all it’s worth.

To put it simply, any disc-based game sold for the Xbox One can only be transferred a single time – it doesn’t matter if a sale is involved or not. Give it to a friend? That’s it. Trade it in at Gamestop? That’s it. This is pretty-well identical to the book-lending service on Kindle, although that’s not ideal either.

Up until the last generation, no one dealt with much hassle when dealing with used games. You could sell most games online one hundred times over, no problem. It hasn’t been until fairly recently where certain companies have decided to complicate things, such as with EA’s now-discontinued Online Pass system. Or with companies that disallow you to delete a saved game. Much like with movies and music, consumers have a belief that the goods they pay for should be tradable, plain and simple. You buy a house, you can sell that house. Rinse and repeat for car, clothing, peripherals and so forth. Could you imagine clothing with DRM? I’m sure it’s not far off. It’s been proven it can happen to our furniture

Used games are something a lot of people care about, so Microsoft is shooting itself in the foot here. When Sony released its humorous “instructional” video yesterday, it had over 80,000 upvotes before the night was over. As of the time of writing, it has about 250,000 upvotes and 6,000,000+ views. Yes, people do care about this.

It’s worth noting that neither the Xbox One nor PlayStation 4 have the ability to trade digitally-purchased games, even just once. This is a bit odd, since even the physical copies will require a code to be used online for the transfer. I think this is a feature both companies know they can get away with, so, they shall get away with it. Even the almighty Valve gives no one the option to trade their games on Steam. As digital consumers, we’re all out of luck where this is concerned – at least for now.

Region-locking – Despite it being 2013 on the calendar, we’re still dealing with some issues that were considered ridiculous 15+ years ago. The Xbox One is region-locked, meaning you won’t be able to play games on your console that weren’t specifically released for that region. If you’re a US gamer, you can say goodbye to UK and Japanese releases – unless you happen to want to import an entirely new console. Sony’s since announced that the PS4 will suffer no such flaw.

Backwards-compatibility – The ability to play older titles on your new console isn’t something that everyone cares about, but those that do care, tend to care a lot (like me). While I completely sympathize with both Microsoft and Sony in this regard – they did both move over to native PC hardware, after all – I’d be one of those willing to pay extra for the ability to play my aging games on my new console (I am not a fan of playing console roulette).

Details are not too clear on the Sony side, but it seems likely that we’ll be able to play PS1, PS2 and PS3 games via Gaikai’s online service. If I had to guess, games will be able to be downloaded, much like they were able to be through PlayStation Network for use on the PS3 and where the PSone was concerned, the PSP. While streaming or downloading these titles is hardly a great solution versus simply being able to pop a disc in, I much prefer having an option over having none at all.

Kinect is Watching You – Really, Microsoft? Kinect has to be connected at all times? I can’t even watch a movie without it monitoring me? That Kinect sensor is going to look awful ugly when people start putting sheets of paper in front of it. Let’s not ignore the fact that it can not only see us, but hear us as well. And if it’s aware at all times… I don’t think I need to say anything more.

The Price-point – I don’t like tackling pricing for most products, because the real value is whatever the consumer sees. I might not think the Xbox One is worth $500, but someone else might think it’d be worth $600. But with all that Microsoft has working against it at the moment, the fact that its console costs $100 more than the PS4 doesn’t bode too well for it. Things sure weren’t this clear even two months ago, but Sony is currently sitting in a very good place, with many begging the company to “not screw it up”. I even saw a “please please please please please please” stated somewhere online.

Final Thoughts

Any one of the caveats mentioned above would be a major pain for a lot of would-be Xbox One adopters to accept, but pile them all together? All that does is make Sony’s console look fantastic. If you asked me a couple of months ago if I were leaning more towards the next Xbox or PlayStation, I would have told you “Xbox”. Even ignoring all of the gotchas I’ve dealt with on the PS3 side, I’m simply more drawn to the catalog on Xbox. I prefer Forza over Gran Turismo, for example. I’ve found the actual experience on the Xbox to be better than the PS3 as well (I have not dabbled with Sony’s recent UI upgrade, however).

Fast-forward to now… I’m definitely all-in on the Sony side. That still feels weird to say, but despite me yearning to play some of the games coming to the Xbox One, all of the caveats are just too much for me to bear. If there’s one thing I hate, it’s a lack of respect from company to legitimate customer – and that’s what this boils down to. With Microsoft’s lack of a remedy to its most hated Xbox One “features”, it’s clear that the company cares more about its own interests than its customers, and it’s willing to take the hit on that. The beneficiary in this event is Sony, which has suddenly gained a massive influx of fans.

PlayStation 4 - Perks
Credit: monkeydcocks

While Reddit isn’t going to be considered a great source for trends to many, it is to me, because the hundreds of thousands of people who frequent channels like /r/games have a passion for gaming. They, like me, don’t like to be screwed-over, or treated badly when we’re the ones handing money over to these companies. In the past week, the amount of vitriol I’ve seen thrown at Microsoft has been unparalleled. Likewise, the amount of love now being sent to Sony, and the pleas for the company to not screw anything up, has been as well.

Currently, the biggest upside to all of these Xbox One hassles is that Sony is trying pretty hard to capitalize on things and win over millions of hearts. But let’s not forget that like Microsoft, Sony is all about making money. At the PS3’s launch, it promised us PS2 backwards-compatibility, the ability to use Linux, and the ability to run Folding@home. Each one of these features were later removed. Anything can happen… anything at all. Sony looks amazing to many right now, but whether or not things remain amazing after launch is yet to be seen. A year from now, we could all be losers – who knows? But as for right now, Sony’s being treated like a god while Microsoft is being spat on. That can’t bode well for the Redmond company.

There’s still a lot of time to go before either console launches, however. Is the mess going to become so big that Microsoft is forced to change some of its upcoming policies? Let’s hope so. Remain vocal, it helps. Better still, put your money where your mouth is. Don’t buy from companies that have a lack of respect for you as a consumer. If everyone adhered to that rule, our marketplace would be very different.

tl;dr: Used game limitations, a daily Internet requirement, region locking, essential Kinect, a complete lack of backwards compatibility and a higher price-point make Microsoft a dull boy.


  • Corey Naish

    Why does MS win “if they fix things”? The PS4 flat out has a better GPU and doesn’t waste 2gb of ram running a DVR operating system…

    • http://techgage.com/ Rob Williams

      It’s not safe to assume at this point that the PS4 is going to be far more powerful than the Xbox One as it appears on paper. I just want to see some real-world developer opinion on it first. For all we know, either console could suffer a development gotcha that makes things slower than we’d expect them to.

      That aside, I’m not assuming Microsoft could “win” even if it DID fix thing (pity I couldn’t use a larger title up there); I’m saying it could at least even out the race. Currently, Sony is leading, and by a mile. Microsoft only has to change a couple of things – aka: respect its customers – to get back in the running. WOULD customers forgive it? That’s hard to say. At this point I don’t trust it… just look at how some of the executives are talking. They’re actually telling people without good Internet access to just buy a 360!

      The sad thing is that the Xbox One will sell in droves -anyway-. A lot of people just don’t care about these downsides.

  • Kougar

    Everyone I’ve run across has been giving Sony the win for the next generation, I have yet to hear a single person that was more enthusiastic about the Xbox One than the PS4. Even a pair of anti-Sony peeps said they were going to switch to PC gaming instead… Such universal dislike of the Xbox One already does not bode well for it.

    • http://techgage.com/ Rob Williams

      For the most part, same here. I’ve seen a lot of support for the Xbox One, but no one “enthusiastic” about it. The main reasons I’ve seen for Xbox One adoption has been friends, plain and simple. You go where your friends are.

  • http://techgage.com/ Jamie Fletcher

    If you include the Wii U too, the only real winner here is… AMD.

    • http://techgage.com/ Rob Williams

      That’s for sure, although few would consider Wii U an actual winner at this point in time. And it’s kind of sad, too… it doesn’t suffer any of these gotchas that the Xbox One has. If only it had more attractive games…

  • Rickard Eneqvist

    I see only one reason to buy XBox One and that is Illumiroom, thats just too awesome. I can only hope that the concept makes its way to PS as well although it would require them to use a “kinetic” camera for the room scan.

    • http://techgage.com/ Rob Williams

      I think Microsoft once came out and said that Illumiroom wouldn’t become available for the Xbox One, as it’s just a “research project”. It -could- technically happen though, but Microsoft has no public plans for it at this time.

  • Hubert J Farnsworth

    I think I might just stick with my PC.

    • http://techgage.com/ Rob Williams

      It seems like the safe bet ;-)

  • Kayden

    A friend of mine was going to buy a XBox One, because he considers console gaming to being cheaper then PC gaming due to new hardware on the PC every year. Despite his pro-console view, he is leaving consoles behind this generation and buying an i5, 16GB of ram and a 760 (when it comes out) all because he can’t stomach the cost of the XBox One and he can’t see putting up with any console DRM when it will turn it into a brick after 24 hours. He doesn’t like Sony’s options either but does consed that they are far better then those offered by Microsoft; though he does see that the PC is better cause he can do more with it than he can with a paper weight.

    This is Microsoft’s market here, people who thought console gaming was better than PC due to cost, but are now jumping ship like rats in a sinking ship. All because Microsoft is being arrogant and doing things they want with no consideration for its consumers, which I like to call the Jobs Effects. Apple first came up with paying for updates for it’s Mac OS and even though they have been innovative, they did things expecting blind loyalty and they generally got it.

    This isn’t the end of consoles as we know it, but I am quite sure that come the next next generation both companies are going to be on this online always DRM and that will finally kill it. Say what you want about the PC but it does offer offline options in one form or another, be it legal or not. The majority of these options though are indie devs, which the PC is still leading the way on, who are just interested in making good games and not restricting it’s customers.

    • http://techgage.com/ Jamie Fletcher

      Doesn’t Like the Sony option and doesn’t want to support Microsoft’s XBox One, so switching to PC? Microsoft wins again.

      (As much as I would like to say Linux and Mac options exists, realistically, they’re still very limited, even as they continue to improve due to Steam.)

      • http://techgage.com/ Rob Williams

        Microsoft only wins because of the Windows license. It doesn’t get a cut of the actual hardware or software like it does with the Xbox.

        • http://techgage.com/ Jamie Fletcher

          Until Microsoft decides to go down a SaaS model for its consumer OS too… Windows 365, I can see it now…

          • http://techgage.com/ Rob Williams

            I could actually see that happening :-|

          • Kayden

            The only reason I do not see this happening is because this is what Microsoft originally set out to do when it decided to go in direct competition with Apple. I do think the tablet market is a different beast but other than that market, I just can’t fathom it happening anytime in the next 10 or even 20 years.

            This would put Linux at the forefront of the OS market for PC manufacturers and then it would dominate the PC gaming market, prefab PCs for companies and etc.

            What I do see happening is M$ putting together a similar system to what we see with the Office 365 suite, where it is subscription based and it pushing it’s own services through the OS.

    • http://techgage.com/ Marfig

      I do see the end of consoles, but not as a result of DRM impositions. The PC gaming market is today flooded with DRM and it didn’t kill it. Even the indie industry has somewhat embraced DRM by accepting to sell their games through online retailers (namely Steam).

      I see the end of the console on the day the PC takes it to the living room. Small-factor PCs, HDMI and PC controllers are today already a reality. It’s the consumer that has been lacking the imagination to turn their PC into a dedicated gaming machine that can sit on the living room and won’t show half of the limitations of a console. In fact, Valve has been a evangelist of this approach. Their changes to steam, their proposed Valve Box, and Gabe’s constant drivel on these matters, a a clear indication the PC plasticity and it’s ability to eventually take on the consoles on their own turf.

      I do agree entirely, however, that the console industry is making everything they can to give the PC transition to the living room a strong welcome.

  • http://techgage.com/ Marfig

    The industry push for an always-online experience has been quite impressive. I say this because, despite all the consumer resistance we still see it happen constantly. Feels like a tug-of-war.

    My real hope is that Microsoft doesn’t change its policy and fails miserably with the Xbox One. The effect this will have on the company could be enormous because the console and office divisions have been the only ones with sizable results. Seeing a company like Microsoft taking a serious hit could scare off a lot of future always-online fuckers. We need a sacrificial lamb for this nonsense to stop. Microsoft is moving right into position. Lets hope they get the chop.

  • Bilal Khan

    PC: ‘I am better!’
    Consoles: ‘At What?!?’
    PC: ‘Everything!’

    • http://techgage.com/ Rob Williams

      Hahaha, spot-on.

Advertisement